Constitution of Bhutan

Constitution of Bhutan
Original Author: Vector-Images.com Converted to SVG by: Oren neu dag · Public domain · source
Document name	Constitution of Bhutan
Promulgation date	2008
Jurisdiction	Kingdom of Bhutan
Language	Dzongkha, English
System	Constitutional monarchy
Branches	Monarchy; Parliament (National Council, National Assembly); Judiciary (Supreme Court, High Court)
History	2001 draft, 2005 draft, 2008 enactment

Constitution of Bhutan

The Constitution of Bhutan is the supreme law of the Kingdom of Bhutan promulgated in 2008 that established a framework for the Druk Gyalpo, bicameral Parliament of Bhutan, and an independent Judiciary of Bhutan while embedding provisions on rights, duties, and governance. It resulted from a series of reforms involving the Fourth Druk Gyalpo Jigme Singye Wangchuck, consultations with the Royal Advisory Council, dialogue with civil society including the Bhutanese Media and Dzongkha Development Commission, and interactions with international actors such as the United Nations Development Programme, International Monetary Fund, and regional neighbors India and China (PRC).

History and Development

The constitutional project traces to the voluntary abdication signals of the Fourth Druk Gyalpo and modernization pressures following events like the 1990s reforms, inputs from the Royal Government of Bhutan, and advice from foreign legal scholars associated with institutions like the Harvard Law School, Oxford University, and the Australian National University. Early steps included the 1999 establishment of the Constitution Drafting Committee and the 2001-2005 drafting phases influenced by comparative texts such as the Constitution of India, United Kingdom unwritten constitution traditions, and written constitutions of Nepal and Thailand. Nationwide consultations were held with dzongkhags and thromdes, and civil society groups including the Bhutan Centre for Media and Democracy participated. Final approval occurred with royal assent by the Fifth Druk Gyalpo Jigme Khesar Namgyel Wangchuck amid a transition to parliamentary democracy and coinciding events such as Bhutan’s accession to the United Nations and engagement with the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation.

Structure and Content

The Constitution organizes state institutions into chapters outlining the Monarchy of Bhutan, a bicameral legislature composed of the National Council (Bhutan) and the National Assembly (Bhutan), an independent judiciary led by the Supreme Court of Bhutan and the High Court of Bhutan, and an executive headed by the King of Bhutan and the Prime Minister of Bhutan. It defines the constitutional status of offices like the Chief Justice of Bhutan, Attorney General of Bhutan, and the Election Commission of Bhutan, as well as administrative divisions such as dzongkhags, gewogs, and thromdes. Provisions on natural resources reference institutions like the Ministry of Agriculture and Forests and the Royal Society for Protection of Nature, while cultural protections mention the Je Khenpo, Monastic Body, and festivals like the Tshechu. The text incorporates principles from international instruments including the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the Convention on the Rights of the Child in framing obligations.

Fundamental Rights and Duties

The Constitution enumerates fundamental rights including freedom of religion with reference to the Drukpa Kagyu tradition and protections for minority faiths, equality guarantees influenced by precedents from the Constitution of India and regional jurisprudence, and socio-economic rights that intersect with policies by the Ministry of Health and the National Statistical Bureau. It establishes duties such as loyalty to the Crown and preservation of environment linked to commitments under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change and conservation work by the Bhutan Trust Fund for Environmental Conservation and Phobjikha Conservation Project. It also guarantees access to education and health services shaped by the Royal University of Bhutan and the Renowned Bhutanese monastic institutions.

Governance: Monarchy, Parliament, and Judiciary

The Constitution defines the hereditary role of the Druk Gyalpo within limits comparable to constitutional monarchies like the United Kingdom while detailing executive functions exercised in concert with the Cabinet of Bhutan and the elected Prime Minister. Legislative processes map the interaction between the National Council (upper house) and the National Assembly (lower house), election mechanisms managed by the Election Commission of Bhutan, and party politics involving parties such as the Bhutan Peace and Prosperity Party and the People's Democratic Party. Judicial review is vested in the Supreme Court of Bhutan, whose judges are nominated by the Royal Judicial Service Commission and confirmed through constitutional procedures influenced by comparative models like the Supreme Court of India and the Constitutional Court of South Africa.

Amendment Procedure

Amendments require prescribed majorities in the Parliament of Bhutan and assent by the King of Bhutan, with some provisions invoking public referenda in a manner similar to processes in the Swiss Confederation and safeguards modeled on experiences from the Constitutional Court of Spain. The Constitution sets higher thresholds for changes touching the monarchy, national identity, and fundamental rights, reflecting lessons from constitutional transitions in regional states such as Nepal and historical reforms seen during the reigns of the Third Druk Gyalpo and Fourth Druk Gyalpo.

Implementation and Impact

Implementation has involved the Royal Civil Service Commission, Ministry of Home and Cultural Affairs, and local governments, facilitating elections overseen by the Election Commission of Bhutan and legal reforms through the Office of the Attorney General. Impact includes the institutionalization of party democracy, modernization of administration aligning with World Bank engagement, development planning through the Gross National Happiness Commission, and increased international legal engagement including cases before the International Court of Justice in other contexts informing Bhutanese practice. The Constitution has also influenced cultural policy administered by the Ministry of Information and Communications and heritage programs such as those at the Textile Museum of Thimphu.

Criticisms and Controversies

Critiques have centered on the handling of citizenship and refugee issues linked to the 1990s expulsions involving Lhotshampa communities, debates over language policy involving Dzongkha and Nepali language groups, tensions between conservation mandates and local livelihoods in areas like the Haa Valley, and concerns about press freedom raised by organizations such as Reporters Without Borders. Legal scholars referencing comparative experiences from the Constitution of India and transitional constitutions in Myanmar and Nepal have debated judicial independence, clarity of separation of powers, and the adequacy of safeguards for minority rights, prompting ongoing dialogue among the Royal Government of Bhutan, civil society organizations, and international partners including the Asian Development Bank.

Category:Law of Bhutan