Advocate General for Scotland

Advocate General for Scotland
CC BY-SA 3.0 · source
Post	Advocate General for Scotland
Department	Law Officers of the Crown
Reports to	Secretary of State for Justice
Seat	London
Appointer	Monarch
Formation	Scotland Act 1998
First	Lynn Scott

Advocate General for Scotland.

The Advocate General for Scotland is the senior Law Officer in the United Kingdom responsible for advising the UK Government on Scots law, representing the Crown in Scottish legal matters, and providing legal opinions in reserved areas defined by the Scotland Act 1998. The post interacts with a wide range of institutions including the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom, the Court of Session, the Lord Advocate, and the Solicitor General for Scotland while operating within the constitutional framework shaped by the Acts of Union 1707, devolution settlements, and subsequent jurisprudence.

History

The office was created by the Scotland Act 1998 during the establishment of the Scottish Parliament and the Scottish Government. Its origins trace to pre-Union legal offices that advised the Crown in Scots law and to roles within the UK Parliament such as the Attorney General for England and Wales. The creation reflected negotiations in the Calman Commission and debates during the passage of devolution legislation in the House of Commons and the House of Lords. Since inception, holders have engaged with landmark legal developments including cases before the European Court of Human Rights, decisions of the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom, and statutory interpretation under the European Communities Act 1972 and later the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018.

Role and Responsibilities

The Advocate General provides authoritative legal advice to the Prime Minister, the Cabinet, and ministerial departments on matters of Scots law and on the compatibility of reserved legislation with devolution settlement provisions. The office represents the Crown and UK ministers in litigation before the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom, the Inner House of the Court of Session, and tribunals including the Tribunal Procedure Committee where devolved competence is contested. Responsibilities include drafting legal opinions, overseeing government litigation strategy, instructing advocates in the Faculty of Advocates, liaising with the Lord Advocate and Solicitor General for Scotland on prosecution and public interest issues, and advising on human rights matters under the Human Rights Act 1998.

Relationship with Scottish and UK Governments

The Advocate General occupies a hybrid constitutional position interacting with both the UK Government and the Scottish Government. The office must balance obligations to the Prime Minister and to the Crown with cooperative working relationships with the First Minister, the Scottish Cabinet Secretary for Justice, and parliamentary committees such as the Scottish Parliament's Justice Committee. Tensions have arisen in the past involving precedent from the Court of Session, devolution disputes taken to the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom, and referrals under section 33 of the Scotland Act 1998. The Advocate General also engages with legal bodies including the Law Society of Scotland, the Faculty of Advocates, and inquiries chaired by figures like Lord Cullen or Lord Bonomy.

Appointment and Tenure

The Advocate General is appointed by the Monarch on the advice of the Prime Minister. Appointees are often Members of the House of Lords or the House of Commons, and may hold ministerial rank within the UK Government. Tenure is at the pleasure of the Monarch, effectively determined by changes in administration following general elections or cabinet reshuffles. Historically, officeholders have included career advocates, former members of the Bar of England and Wales, and politicians who served in cabinets under prime ministers such as Tony Blair, David Cameron, Theresa May, and Boris Johnson.

Officeholders

Notable holders include early incumbents who shaped the post after the Scotland Act 1998. Officeholders have come from diverse backgrounds including members of the Conservative Party, the Labour Party, and crossbench legal appointees. Several have had prior service as members of the Faculty of Advocates, as crown counsel, or as members of the House of Lords. Officeholders often liaise with counterparts such as the Lord Advocate and the Attorney General for England and Wales.

Notable Decisions and Controversies

The Advocate General has been central to high-profile legal questions involving devolution disputes, referrals to the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom, and compatibility assessments under the Human Rights Act 1998. Controversies have involved judicial review challenges in the Court of Session, disagreements with the Scottish Government over reserved competence, and high-stakes litigation related to constitutional events like EU membership matters and the aftermath of the 2014 Scottish independence referendum. The office has also been scrutinised in parliamentary debates in the House of Commons and the House of Lords regarding legal advice provided on controversial legislation.

Category:Scots law Category:United Kingdom law officers