Good Neighbor Policy

Good Neighbor Policy
source
Name	Good Neighbor Policy
Date	1933–1945 (prominent)
Location	Latin America
Type	Foreign policy of the United States
Cause	Great Depression, Banana Wars, Clark Memorandum
Target	Non-intervention, Pan-Americanism
Participants	Franklin D. Roosevelt, Cordell Hull, Sumner Welles
Outcome	Improved relations, World War II alliance, Organization of American States

Good Neighbor Policy. A cornerstone of Franklin D. Roosevelt's administration, this foreign policy approach fundamentally redefined United States relations with Latin America during the 1930s and 1940s. It formally repudiated the Big Stick ideology and Dollar Diplomacy of previous eras, emphasizing non-intervention, mutual respect, and Pan-Americanism. The policy sought to foster hemispheric solidarity, a goal that became critically important with the onset of World War II.

Background and origins

The policy emerged from a confluence of domestic and international pressures following the Great Depression. Previous decades were marked by repeated United States Marine Corps interventions under the Roosevelt Corollary, leading to prolonged occupations in nations like Nicaragua and Haiti. These Banana Wars generated widespread resentment across the Caribbean and Central America, epitomized by events like the Sandino Rebellion. Diplomatic reassessments, notably the 1928 Clark Memorandum authored by J. Reuben Clark, began to challenge the legal basis for intervention. The ideological shift was signaled by President Herbert Hoover's tour of Latin America and was fully embraced by his successor, Franklin D. Roosevelt, who first articulated the "good neighbor" phrase in his 1933 inaugural address.

Key principles and policies

The doctrine was built upon the principle of non-intervention in the internal and external affairs of sovereign states. This was concretely demonstrated by the abrogation of the Platt Amendment, which had granted the United States the right to intervene in Cuba, and the withdrawal of U.S. Marines from Haiti. Secretary of State Cordell Hull and diplomat Sumner Welles championed policies of reciprocal trade, culminating in agreements like the Hull–Sánchez Treaty with Colombia. The administration also moved away from Gunboat diplomacy, instead promoting cultural exchanges and economic cooperation through frameworks discussed at the Montevideo Convention and the Buenos Aires Peace Conference. This "hands-off" approach extended to recognizing revolutionary governments, such as that of Lázaro Cárdenas in Mexico.

Implementation and effects

Implementation involved significant diplomatic gestures, including Roosevelt's attendance at the 1936 Inter-American Conference for the Maintenance of Peace in Buenos Aires. The policy was tested by events like the 1938 Mexican oil expropriation, where the Roosevelt administration chose negotiation over confrontation. Its most profound effect was unifying the hemisphere against external threats during World War II. All Latin American nations except Argentina and Chile eventually severed relations with the Axis powers. Key nations like Brazil granted vital Allied airbase rights, while the Mexican Air Force's Escuadrón 201 saw combat. Wartime cooperation was institutionalized through the Inter-American Defense Board and the provision of Lend-Lease aid.

Criticism and legacy

Critics argued the policy often accommodated authoritarian strongmen, such as Anastasio Somoza García in Nicaragua and Rafael Trujillo in the Dominican Republic, to maintain stability and counter Fascism. Some historians contend economic dominance by U.S. corporations, like the United Fruit Company, continued under a more polite facade. Despite this, its legacy is foundational for modern Inter-American relations. It directly paved the way for the 1947 Inter-American Treaty of Reciprocal Assistance (Rio Treaty) and the 1948 charter of the Organization of American States. The policy also influenced later initiatives like the Alliance for Progress under President John F. Kennedy.

End of the policy

The cohesive Pan-Americanism fostered by the policy began to fracture in the early Cold War. Strategic anti-communism increasingly superseded non-intervention, leading the United States to resume covert and overt interventions. This shift was evident in the 1954 overthrow of Jacobo Árbenz in Guatemala, orchestrated by the Central Intelligence Agency. Subsequent events, including the Bay of Pigs Invasion in Cuba and support for anti-communist regimes during the Central American crisis, marked a definitive return to interventionist practices. The ideological framework of the Good Neighbor Policy was effectively abandoned, though its spirit of cooperation continued to inform diplomatic rhetoric.

Category:Foreign policy of the United States Category:History of the Americas Category:20th-century diplomatic conferences